Don't Carve A Pumpkin For Halloween- Carve A Turnip Jack O'Lantern

Why you should carve turnip jack o lanterns instead of pumpkins for halloween

In remembrance of the original Jack O’lantern, which were NOT carved out of pumpkins, try something so old it’s new. Carve a Turnip Jack O’Lantern for Halloween just like the Irish, Scots and Brits used to before bright orange pumpkins became the norm. Or do as the French do in the Northern parts of France and carve a beet lantern. Read on to learn more about this fun project.

Getting to the root of it. Why carve a turnip?

A few years ago I was searching the internet to see if I could find a pumpkin patch near our house (in the south of France). Never found one by the way. They were all located too far from us, mainly outside of Paris.

As usual, I got sucked into the internet black hole of information and came upon some interesting facts about the tradition of carving pumpkin Jack O’lanterns that was so different, so new to me, I actually didn’t believe it when I first read it.

Original-Irish-JackOlantern** photo-icon.50xpngPhoto source: Irish turnip (rutabaga) lantern on display in Ireland at the National Museum of Ireland- Country life.

The original Jack-O-Lantern

The original European Jack-O-lanterns- named for the Irish myth , were carved mainly from turnips and other roots such as rutabagas, potatoes or beets and looked truly grotesque and monstrous compared to today’s festive or goofy carved orange pumpkins.

In fact, it wasn’t until the mid 1800’s, when Irish and Scottish immigrants brought their custom of carving lanterns out of roots to North America that the tradition changed.

The newly arrived immigrants discovered North American orange pumpkins were perfect for carving and so began the new custom of carving orange pumpkins which is now popular throughout the world, not just in North America.

I decided to give turnip carving a go and created several turnip Jack O’lanterns this Halloween with my daughter. Of course we also carved a pumpkin and made pumpkins seeds.

See also: 10 things you didn’t know about Halloween in France

Advantages of carving  turnip Jack O’lanternsHere is one of the turnips we carve this halloween

photo source (annieandre.com)

To be honest, I didn’t have a lot of faith in carving turnips into Jack O’lanterns. I thought they would be more difficult than carving a pumpkin because I kept reading how the Irish and Scots found  pumpkins easy to carve.

To my surprise, it was just as easy if not easier to carve a turnip. In a matter of 15 minutes, my daughter and I had carved several adorably grotesque looking turnip Jack O’lanterns. Something you can’t really do with a pumpkin because you have to first gut the pumpkin and then slowly work your knife through the thick skin of the pumpkin to carve it. Both can be very time consuming.

Here are 9 benefits to carving turnips and roots into Jack O’Lanterns instead of pumpkins.

  1. No scooping out messy seeds, no big pumpkin mess
  2. Turnips are smaller and more portable than pumpkins so you can easily use them as actual Jack O’lanterns or hang them from a tree outside.
  3. Turnips are also cheaper so you can afford to make dozens of carved turnips to display around the house, on your windowsills or outside.
  4. You can easily let your kids do a lot of the work because it’s easier for them to scoop than a big heavy pumpkin.
  5. With its reddish white exterior and root like characteristics, turnips look more interesting than a carved pumpkin. Maybe scarier?
  6. Candles tends to flicker more in a turnip because they are less protected than in a pumpkin which makes the turnip look spookier….. But the candle tends do get blown out more easily as a result. (not a positive)
  7. Unlike pumpkins, turnips and various other roots are fairly easy to find almost everywhere all year round. Even in France.
  8. No waste! After you scoop out the innards of the turnips, you can use the guts to make yummy mashed turnips.
  9. You can carve turnips and roots all year round into different things like votive holders unlike pumpkins which only look appropriate during Halloween. (see photos below)

English Heritage wants you to use turnips due to a possible pumpkin shortage

Why you should carve turnip jack o lanterns instead of pumpkins for halloweenphoto-icon.50xpngPhoto source of English Heritage turnip carver and carved turnips

There have been several attempts to revive this almost forgotten tradition of carving turnip Jack O’lanterns.

In 2015, a pumpkin shortage led to the English Heritage calling for Brits to rediscover and bring back the original tradition of turnip carving to address reduced supplies of pumpkins caused by wet weather.

The English Heritage even installed a number of ghoulishly carved turnips at the Dover Castle to inspire people but I don’t think it’s really caught on yet but time will tell.

Tools you need to carve a turnip or other root

carve-turnip-tools

how to carve and scoop out guts of a turnip to make a jack o'lantern

photo-icon.50xpng Photo source: Diane Gilleland via Makezine.

The tools you need to cut and carve a turnip are pretty similar to a pumpkin.

  • A knife to cut off the top
  • Something to scoop out the guts- a melon baller scoop works way better than a spoon. The edges on a melon baller are sharper.
  • A smaller blade to carve the details of your scary face onto the turnip.
  • A poking tool might come in handy if you want to poke small holes into the sides of the turnip and run string through the holes so you can hang the turnip from a tree or something.

Turnip and root carving inspiration

When it comes to carving you’re turnip, which actually look terrifying when carved, you are limited only by your imagination. Here a few photos to wet your inspiration.

English-heritage-turnips

photo-icon.50xpngPhoto source of English Heritage carved turnips

Hang a bunch of turnip Jack O’lanterns in the yard

turnip-lantern-Mstewart

Turnips don’t weigh very much so they can easily be hung from a tree in the backyard or on your front doorstep. Carry them on your trick or treats too.

Carve a rutabaga

ugly-carved-turnips

Photo source Munchies.vice

In addition to turnips, rutabagas were also carved into jack O’lanterns. These guys look even scarier than turnips with their brown skin and extruding roots that remind me of mole hairs.

carved-rutabaga for halloween

photo-icon.50xpngphoto source = The invisible underground

Make a simple turnip votive for any time of the year

turnip votive from martha stewart

photo-icon.50xpngPhoto source Martha Stewart

For a more elegant turnip that you can use all year round, turn that turnip into a tea light holder to put on the dinner table or coffee table.  Martha Stewart says to use varying sizes for the most interesting display and not to leave lit candles unattended. DUH!

carved-turnip-lanterns

Photo source = Lovely Greens

Head over to Lovely greens to learn how to make these cute carved turnip lanterns.

Carve other roots like potatoes

carve-potato-halloween

photo-icon.50xpngPhoto source = Odyssey

If turnips are not available or you want to try your hand at carving other roots and vegetable like the Irish, Scots and English used to, just walk into your kitchen and take a look in your vegetable drawer. Pull out a potato, a beet, a butternut squash or a rutabaga and start carving away.

The Sugar Beet Lantern carving customs in Northern France

boulonnais-betterave

photo-icon.50xpngphoto source= ville deLongvilliers

As I mentioned in this article-Why the French hate Halloween and how to celebrate it anyways., the French don’t really celebrate Halloween, so carving pumpkins isn’t really that popular either.

However there is a region in the North of France where the French have a tradition of carving beets. Not any old garden variety beet- they carve huge sugar beets.

Grimacing Beets of Lorraine “les Betteraves Grimaçantes”


carved-betravephoto source: B@ch’ Boetz

The children of Lorraine, a historical region in northeast France which borders Belgium, Luxembourg and Germany have a tradition of carving grimacing beet lanterns “les Betteraves Grimaçantes”.

A small candle is placed in the carved sugar beet lantern and placed on the windowsill on November 1st- “All saints day” which happens to be the day after Halloween. This special night is called “nuit des betteraves grimaçantes” in French or “Rommelbootzen” in German which translates to “The night of the grimacing beets”.

la-nuit-de-betterave

photo-icon.50xpngphoto source = Blog d’air

Decorated Beets of Boulonnais during Christmas

poster-guenel

In Boulonnais, a coastal area in northern France near Calais and Boulogne-sur-Mer, there is a carved beet lantern festival called “la fête des guénels”.

A Guénels is a carved beet lantern and is the middle aged phonetic spelling for the word Gai Noel.

guenel festival in Northern France

Photo source of kids at Christmas with carved beets.

The custom of beet carving in this region is centred around the story of Petit Pierre.

There are several versions of this story but the gist of the folklore is that Petit Pierre, a very poor boy wanted to make some money for Christmas. So on the eve of Christmas, he carved a face into a beet and placed a candle in it to use as a lantern to illuminate the dark night so he could go door to door asking the bourgeois boulonnais for money. (sounds similar to Halloween doesn’t it?)

Free beets for everyone

Although it sounds a lot like Halloween and trick-or-treating and perhaps is related to the Celtic tradition, it is actually celebrated for Christmas but only in the Boulonnais area of France which has it’s own unique customs and traditions.

The municipality of Boulogne drops truck loads of huge beets in the street which the Kids can then go around collecting which they will then carve and use to go door to door asking for treats while singing the traditional song called « Ô Guénel » .

photo of kids in beet carving competition for guénels

photo source “of kids in beet carving competition”

There is also a festival of carved beets called  “la fête des guénels” with a beet carving contest. After the contest, children parade in the streets « défilé des guénels » asking passer-byers for sweets «les  sucreries» while again singing a traditional song called « Ô Guénel » .

Happy root carving.

our carved turnip experiment

About the Author

Annie André Is a half Thai, half French Canadian/American freelance writer, digital marketer and author of THE LIVE IN FRANCE GUIDE: an expat travel and lifestyle blog featuring destination guides, inspiration, travel tips, personal advice and anecdotes on working, living and playing in France. ( Equal parts weird, wacky and wonderful).